Summary

Starry-Eyed for Christmas is a different type of Christmas story that was a reality check for some of the characters as they unexpectedly share their holiday with a newcomer in their midst.

4-STAR REVIEW: STARRY-EYED FOR CHRISTMAS by Sheila Roberts

The Description

Publication Date: October 18, 2025

Starr Conner is longing to find the perfect man. She hasn’t found him in her beach town of Port Haven. She just knows he exists. Somewhere. Maybe this year Santa will come through for her.
John Smith is new to the area. Actually, John Smith is new to Earth. Making his visit in the special human form provided for him, he gets to experience a taste of life there. And he’s just in time for the festival called Christmas. Long before he meets Santa, he meets someone even better: Starr.
Starr is thinking her dream man might have finally arrived, but there’s just one problem. Earth’s atmosphere isn’t as welcoming as she is, and much as he wants to, John can’t stay permanently. Can an out of this world love conquer all?

The Review

Sheila Roberts’ Starry-Eyed for Christmas is an out-of-this-world love story with an engaging cover, characters, and a holiday feel.

Starr and John hit it off from the start, as their paths cross in her small town of Port Haven, Washington. Starr is looking for love with her perfect man. John enters Earth in his human form to gain new experiences, and it’s interesting to see his introduction to Earth and how he’s guided through it. But is it possible for them to be a couple? And what happens if he’s outed as an alien?

John has a two-week time limit on Earth, and there’s a lot packed into it as he maneuvers through life in his human form. I liked how he kept comparing the Earthers to the people of his planet, and it was funny how he expressed himself, which definitely brought smiles to my face. There are vivid descriptions throughout as we see things through his eyes and can almost feel what he’s feeling for the first time. The Christmas festival has sights and sounds for John to take in and enjoy, especially with Starr at his side.

The story has multiple storylines and a good flow, with lots of suspicion from Starr’s friends as they question his words and actions. Milton,  her boyfriend until John shows up, leads the way. His demeanor changes, though, when he realizes who/what John really is. Surprises and unexpected moments come throughout. The story closes with an unexpected, emotional ending.

Starry-Eyed for Christmas is a different type of Christmas story that was a reality check for some of the characters as they unexpectedly share their holiday with a newcomer in their midst.

Buy Links

Amazon Add to Goodreads

About The Author

USA Today and Publisher’s Weekly best-selling author Sheila Roberts has written over sixty books under different names, ranging from devotional, self-improvement and memoir to fiction. Her novels have been turned into movies for the Lifetime, Hallmark and Great American Family channels. Her 2024 Christmas novel, The Merry Matchmaker, received a starred review from Publisher’s Weekly. Sheila is happily married and lives in the Pacific Northwest.

WebsiteInstagramYouTubeGoodreadsAmazon-SocialBookbub

REVIEW AUTHOR

JoAnne
JoAnne
JoAnne Weiss, nee Montalbano, was born and raised in NYC until moving to CT with her family when she was 16 and she's never left. Married for 43 years with one grown son, she works in an elementary school office where she's been since it opened in 2003. Prior to that, she was an accountant in several corporations before becoming a stay at home mom for 12 years. JoAnne enjoys reading, traveling, spending time with her family, and extended family as well as with friends. She enjoys cooking and rarely uses a recipe the way it was intended but instead uses them and cooking shows to give her new ideas and suggestions. JoAnne has a huge bucket list of places she'd like to visit but has been lucky enough to travel to England, Italy, the Caribbean, Mexico, Canada, and many states in the U.S. including Hawaii, California, Nevada, Arizona, and Maine among others. Some of JoAnne's favorite genres include contemporary romance, chick-lit, romantic suspense, and historical romances including regency and those set in the west. JoAnne is on several author's street teams and enjoys interacting with many of them on Facebook as well as reading their newsletters. She has been lucky enough to meet some of her favorite authors among them Susan Mallery, Debbie Macomber, Nora Roberts, Meg Tilly, Beatriz Williams, and Marie Bostwick. JoAnne took a road trip with her sister in the fall of 2019 and visited Nora Roberts' bookstore in Boonsboro, Maryland for an authors' signing. She hopes to do more of this in the future. JoAnne leaves reviews for all books she reads on Goodreads and her reviews can be found at https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/5001736?ref=nav_mybooks JoAnne currently reviews for - NovelsAlive.com. Previously she reviewed for Romancing-the-Book.com and RomanceJunkies.com both of which have since closed. Payment is in the form of receiving free books to read and review. Her mantra is too many books and not enough time!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -
Starry-Eyed for Christmas is a different type of Christmas story that was a reality check for some of the characters as they unexpectedly share their holiday with a newcomer in their midst.4-STAR REVIEW: STARRY-EYED FOR CHRISTMAS by Sheila Roberts