GUEST BLOG: Do’s and Don’ts of Writing Cozy Mysteries by ML Erdahl Plus Giveaway!


Reader's FavoriteDos of Writing Cozies

  • Do learn how to write. Skip this step at your own risk or be forced to deal with heartache, because once you are armed with the proper knowledge, you’ll have to rewrite an entire novel. There are numerous books on the subject, local writing associations, and conferences that are dedicated to teaching potential authors the craft of storytelling. These sources teach important fundamentals such as the three story act, the development of characters, the importance of setting, as well as the all important writing commandment Show Don’t Tell.
  • Do read various cozy mystery authors. Win-win! You get to read your favorite cozies, but tell everyone that you’re doing it for research purposes. The best part—it isn’t even a lie. Reading authors in the genre help you develop your own instinct as to what belongs when imagining your own story.
  • Do imagine your main character’s personality in extensive detail. If you are passionate about baking, maybe make that your main character’s profession. Dog walking, innkeeper, tour guide, bounty hunter, and my own main character Crystal Rainey’s profession, wilderness guide—the options are endless. However, a character isn’t defined by their job alone. Are they brave and determined? Foolhardy and adventurous? What idiosyncrasies do they have? Think of the television show Monk—Tony Shaloub’s character suffered from OCD, but that personality difference made him memorable. My main character can’t lie under pressure. When confronted by a suspect, she invariably suffers a brain freeze, and can’t come up with convincing lies. It isn’t an ideal trait to have if you’re an amateur sleuth nosing around in other people’s business, but it makes for some humorous interactions.
  • Do develop your setting. Is it a quaint fictitious town? Then populate it with quirky, fun characters and interesting businesses. Maybe there is a grouchy old man missing an eye, but every Halloween he puts on an eyepatch and decorates his home to look like a pirate ship while handing out full-sized candy bars. Dig deep and flesh these characters out, because they will become like old friends to the reader, who look forward to their appearance time and time again. Remember my advice about reading other authors? Carlene O’Connors Death in an Irish Village is a prime example as to how the reader can be transported to a new location with an author’s words. I wanted nothing more than to sit in the pub, eating brown bread, sipping Guinness, and watching the murder case unfold. The setting is important to imparting the cozy in your mystery. Make a reader snuggle up with your book and imagine interacting with your cast of characters wherever your story takes place.
  • Do introduce the murder victim and summarily kill them off. Don’t be shy! Just finish them off in whatever manner you please to get the mystery started. Ideally, this needs to be in the first ten percent on the novel. The murder is a call-to-action for all cozy readers, who want to solve the murder along with the amateur sleuth. Engage your audience so they can begin looking for clues alongside the sleuth.
  • Do get your main character started by laying out a trail of clues—or are they red herrings? Whether it is a juicy bit of gossip, a suspect caught lingering around the scene of the crime, or news wheedled out of law enforcement, information will be interpreted by your main character. Some of this will be true clues that assist in solving the crime. Other tidbits may be either misunderstood by your sleuth, or sometimes intentionally left by a suspect to throw them off the trail (Remember—If the clue giver turns out to be the murderer, they aren’t above a little deception to cover it up!). These pieces of evidence not only propel the story forward, but keep the readers pondering the meaning of each new hint you choose to share with them.
  • Do culminate your cozy murder mystery with the solving of the crime. There is no secret how cozy mysteries will end. The main character corners the suspect and ensures they are turned into law enforcement. The predictability of the outcome isn’t the point. The important part of the story is the journey you took to get there. If you’ve pulled this off perfectly, the reader will close the book with a smile and say, “Oh, I didn’t see that coming, but it makes so much sense!” This feat of writing is accomplished by synthesizing the clue drops and red herrings into a satisfying climax. If you’ve laid a false trail, reveal why it wasn’t the real deal and how the reader could have determined that. Most important, you have to leave a realistic way for the reader to have sussed it out. After all, that’s why they bought the ticket for this ride in the first place.

Accept Criticism

Donts of Writing Cozy Mysteries

  • Don’t get complacent when motivating your main character. One of the common complaints about cozies is, “Why is the main character even investigating in the first place?!” Seriously, who stumbles onto a dead body, and declares, “How fun! I want to get involved in this situation.” However, while all genres benefit from what is called a suspension of disbelief from its fans, you can’t get lazy. Cozy readers will accept an amateur sleuth investigating and solving a crime, but only to an extent. As an author, it is your job to make it plausible that your main character needs to solve this particular crime. Is their bed and breakfast shut down until the murder is solved? Are they the primary suspect? Both of these could be strong motivators. If you gloss over this step, the reader may give up on the story even if it continues into a masterfully written mystery.
  • Don’t reveal the murderer to be an obscure character that the reader will need to flip backward in the book to recall. This infuriates cozy mystery fans, and they won’t pick up your next book. If your murderer is Susan Smith mentioned briefly on page eight, I don’t blame them for giving up, either.
  • Don’t let the crime steer the story in a dark direction. How do you keep a macabre subject like murder in the proper tone? Have the crime happen off-scene. The protagonist can stumble upon the body, or hear about it from other characters. This spares the reader from experiencing the act itself. I loved CSI-Las Vegas as much as the next person, but the main character of a cozy is an amateur sleuth, and doesn’t have access to police resources. Therefore, don’t have them sift through a gruesome murder scene looking for clues. If you start going into grisly details or forensic procedures, you are venturing towards the police procedural genre.
  • Don’t include explicit sex. Intimacy can be part of a cozy, but needs to happen off-camera. This can be accomplished by cutting a scene before the characters retire to the bedroom and picking up at the breakfast table the next morning. A good reality check—If you’re embarrassed for your parents to read your material, you might have wandered into the romantic suspense genre.
  • Don’t be trite. There are a lot of cozy mystery tropes that readers have come to expect. Cuddly pets, love triangles, cops who threaten the sleuth for being too nosy, overheard conversations, etc… If written well, these are classic hallmarks of the cozy genre. If they are done poorly, they come across as tired cliches that make for a boring read. Therefore, ponder how to either put a unique spin on the topics or even breaking the trope altogether. Maybe the main character’s best friend is an absolutely atrocious baker and everyone politely chokes down her cookies throughout the entire book. An example from my series is my main character’s cat named Elf. Instead of being a sweet part of the setting, Elf (Evil Little Feline) is capricious and constantly swiping at people with his claws. Despite this, Crystal loves her cat, which shows her character as being a big softy, like we all are with our own pets. This slight twist of the sweet cozy pet trope gave it fresh life, while also feeling comfortable to the reader.

I hope these tips help when you decide to put pen to paper. If you have any questions or comments, feel free to reach out to me at or through social media. I’m on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter.

If you make the leap from reader to author, I urge you to check out a local writing association, and start connecting with others through social media. The writing community is possibly the most positive, supportive bunch of people you will ever meet. Complete strangers will offer advice, encouragement, and support, and often end up being life long friends.

About The Book

A Seattle Wilderness Mystery: Book 2
Publication Date: January 13, 2021

SPRING UPON A CRIME COVERWilderness guide Crystal Rainey leads a group of college students to a private campground amidst the awe-inspiring Olympic Rain Forest. The excursion is ruined when the charming hostess Roxie is discovered standing over the land owner’s body, murder weapon in hand.

Enlisted to investigate the crime to absolve her friend, Crystal descends on the quiet city of Forks to find loggers, developers, and eco-protesters circling the property, intent on either exploiting or protecting the bastion of old-growth forest. The list of suspects is intimidating. Can Crystal find answers in a community determined to keep her in the dark?


Buy Links

Amazon Barnes & Noble iBooks Kobo

GiveawaySpring Upon a Crime Giveaway
a Rafflecopter giveaway

About The Author

ML ErdahlAward-winning author ML Erdahl lives amidst the trees of the Pacific Northwest, where he pens humorous cozy mystery novels set in the wilderness he has spent his lifetime exploring. The only thing slowing him down is when his adorable rescue dogs, Skip and Daisy, demand to be pet and cuddled on his lap while he types. When he’s not working away in front of a computer, you can find him gardening, hiking, or grumbling to his wife, Emily, about the perpetual Northwest winter rain that prevents him from going outside.


Blog Tour Schedule

February 22 – I’m All About Books – SPOTLIGHT

February 22 – Christa Reads and Writes – REVIEW

February 22 – Novels Alive – GUEST POST

February 23 – Cozy Up With Kathy – AUTHOR INTERVIEW

February 23 – Celticlady’s Reviews – SPOTLIGHT

February 23 – My Reading Journeys – REVIEW


February 24 – Reading, Writing & Stitch-Metic – GUEST POST

February 24 – Christy’s Cozy Corners – REVIEW

February 24 – Laura’s Interests – REVIEW

February 24 – The Ninja Librarian – REVIEW, CHARACTER INTERVIEW

February 25 – Literary Gold – REVIEW

February 25 – Mysteries with Character – REVIEW

February 25 – Sapphyria’s Book Reviews – SPOTLIGHT

February 26 – I Read What You Write – SPOTLIGHT

February 26 – Novels Alive – REVIEW

February 26 – Here’s How It Happened – SPOTLIGHT

February 27 – Books a Plenty Book Reviews – REVIEW, GUEST POST

February 27 – Brooke Blogs – CHARACTER GUEST POST

February 27 – Escape With Dollycas Into A Good Book – SPOTLIGHT

February 28 – A Blue Million Books – AUTHOR INTERVIEW

February 28 – Maureen’s Musings – SPOTLIGHT

Dayna Linton
Dayna Linton
Dayna is the owner of not only Novels Alive but of Day Agency, a full-service self-publishing agency for independent authors. She has been assisting independent authors to achieve their dreams of becoming published authors for over 15 years. From New York Times and USA Today Bestselling authors to the first-time author to every author in between. Dayna is a self-professed bibliophile. While dancing has always been her first love, reading came as a very, very close second, with gardening coming in as a close third. Dayna is also the divorced mom of four adult children and a very proud grandma. She is also a web designer, social media specialist, book blogger, and reviewer. She's a long-time Disney lover and a Utah Jazz, Utah Utes, and Dallas Cowboys fan. See Dayna's reviews here: Dayna's Reviews


  1. I appreciate you hosting me today, and I hope my tips on writing are of assistance to anyone thinking about putting pen to paper for their first cozy mystery. When I began writing, established authors were free with their advice and time, and this is the least I can do to pay it forward. Good luck, happy writing, and enjoy the mysteries of life!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -